Skip to main content

This website will be unavailable for essential maintenance from 4.45pm on Wednesday 18 November. It will be restored as soon as possible and we thank you for your patience.

Mayor of London logo London Assembly logo
Home

TFL’s 30 Year Contract with First Group TOL (4)

  • Reference: 2020/4108
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
When TfL acquired Tramtrack Croydon Limited in 2008, the same Operating Agreement that governs the PFI Concessionaires’ 30 Year Contract with First Group TOL was retained by TfL, leaving TfL in a very weak position in terms of enforcing contract terms relating to safety, as we now know. Was any analysis of alternative options undertaken at the time which would have addressed this risk? Who was responsible for the decision not to demand alterations to that contract?

TfL’s 30 Year Contract with First Group TOL (3)

  • Reference: 2020/4107
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
In the “Trams Update Note”, dated 25 May 2017 and released in response to Question 2019/17340, it is stated that the TfL/TOL contract contains provision for termination in the event of “material and serious default” that would would require TfL to evidence: • TOL have failed in obligations to “have proper safety systems and implement them”; • “Systemic Failure, not just evidence of individual incidents although multiple incidents” • TOL’s failure to remedy defaults over time TfL’s General Counsel concludes that TfL would not be justified in exercising this clause. In your opinion, noting that you are also a lawyer...

TfL’s 30 Year Contract with First Group TOL (2)

  • Reference: 2020/4106
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
In fact a “Trams Update Note”, dated 25 May 2017 and released in response to Question 2019/17340, clearly shows that TfL did in fact consider terminating the TOL contract but decided it was not possible because (a) the Operating Agreement does not contain any rights to step in and take over operations in the event of a failure of service (or any other reason) (b) TfL would still be required to pay First Group fees less profit even if the Agreement were suspended owing to First Group’s breach; and (c) TfL’s rights to terminate for First Group’s default are limited...

TfL’s 30 Year Contract with First Group TOL (1)

  • Reference: 2020/4105
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
Question 2019/0150 asked you very specifically whether you “as Chair of TfL, considered the possibility of ending FirstGroup TOL's 30-year contract and re-tendering the operation”. In response you stated “TfL does not have any plans to change the contractual arrangement in place at this time,” which you must surely agree does not answer the question?

2014 Report from CIRAS about Fatigue from TOL Croydon Tram Drivers

  • Reference: 2020/4104
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
Your response to Question 2020/3651 is incomplete. For the avoidance of doubt, was anyone at TfL aware of the March 2014 CIRAS Report about Fatigue from TOL Croydon Tram Drivers between the dates of 4 March 2014 (when CIRAS received the report) and 2 July 2014 (when IA 13744 was published)?

Source of Victim-Blaming Statements reflected in TfL’s Bus Safety Data Release

  • Reference: 2020/4103
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
Referring to your response to Question 2020/3655, what is the source of the Victim-Blaming Statements reflected in TfL’s Bus Safety Data Release and which TfL Executive approved the publication of this information every quarter?

Audit Conclusion of IA 16767

  • Reference: 2020/4102
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
The draft version of the Internal Audit which TfL was undertaking at the time of the Sandilands Crash (IA 16767 ,“Trams Management of Operational Risk”) shows a conclusion of “Adequately Controlled”. On what date was this draft Audit written?

IA 16767 - Trams Management of Operational Risk Audit (8)

  • Reference: 2020/4101
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
Starting from 1 September 2016, please provide me with all documentation (initiating letters, terms of reference, emails, handwritten notes, audit drafts) associated with or referring to IA 16767, including all correspondence relating to its cancellation.

IA 16767 - Trams Management of Operational Risk Audit (7)

  • Reference: 2020/4100
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
If the RAIB, SNC Lavalin, Metropolitan Police, ORR and the Coroner were provided with copies of draft audit IA 16767, on what dates did this happen?

IA 16767 - Trams Management of Operational Risk Audit (6)

  • Reference: 2020/4099
  • Question by: Keith Prince
  • Meeting date: 19 November 2020
Can you confirm that TfL provided RAIB, SNC Lavalin, Metropolitan Police, ORR and the Coroner copies of draft audit IA 16767 and all communications and collected data associated with the suspended audit?
Subscribe to