Skip to main content
Mayor of London logo London Assembly logo
Home

EIR - Area 1 and Area 2, Silvertown Square [Nov 2026]

Key information

Request reference number: MGLA261026-0507

Date of response:

Summary of request

Under the Environmental Information Regulations 2004, please provide the following about the two leases granted by GLA Land and Property Ltd over Area 1 and Area 2, Silvertown Square, North Woolwich Road, London, to Dockyards London Ltd (company 13948902, now Silverworks Island Ltd). The Area 2 lease is dated 9 September 2022.

Copies of the leases were released under request MGLA090126-1628 with the rent, turnover rent, lease length and break dates redacted. The response to request MGLA100726-3578 said the GLA does not hold rent information, although both leases contain rent and turnover-rent clauses.

  1. The rent, turnover rent, lease term and break dates in each lease, unredacted.
  2. The rent, turnover rent, service charge and any other payments invoiced to, and received from, the tenant in each financial year from 2022-23 to date.
  3. If you withhold any of this information, the specific exception relied on for each item and your public interest test.

The venue has traded publicly since 2022, the letting was not competitively tendered, and the Area 2 lease contains a covenant (clause 5.2) not to let other parts of the estate for electronic and dance music events. Regulation 12(2) requires a presumption in favour of disclosure, and there is a strong public interest in knowing whether public land was let at best value when no competition was held and exclusivity was granted to one operator

Our response

Firstly, in respect of why we did not do a competitive competition for the lease, the Silvertown site is subject to a development agreement with The Silvertown Partnership (TSP) (who were appointed by way of a Regulated procurement process), and they have the right to drawdown all the land for redevelopment in phased way. This means that the site can only otherwise be used temporarily, which often means taking advantage of ad hoc requirements and requests for land on a short-term basis. This is an approach that we have taken on Silvertown and have leased space on that part of the site not occupied by TSP to several different occupiers for various terms. This approach is more flexible and responsive than running a series of competitive processes. It is also important to say that land transactions such as leases do not require a competitive process to be undertaken.

In respect of Clause 5.2, this clause was requested by the occupier as part of the negotiations. The request was to avoid another music venue on the Silvertown site. This request was based on the investment and commitment required by the occupier to establish their venue. From GLAP’s perspective, the agreement to this clause did not have any major impact because the rest of the Silvertown site is either (a) already occupied by TSP for the purposes of redevelopment, or (b) occupied by other meanwhile uses. There was no reasonable expectation that it would be feasible to lease another part of the site for a similar use.

Furthermore, with regard to your request for information relating to GLA meeting its best consideration obligation - the lease is for less than 7 years, therefore the statutory obligation to achieve best consideration reasonably obtainable (required under section 333ZC of the GLA Act 1999 (as amended)) does not apply to this land transaction. 

In relation to best value, GLA officers are confident that the terms of the lease represent best value to GLA/GLAP, based on:

  • The level of rent paid to GLA by the Tenant
  • The short-term nature of the leasehold, 
  • The investment required to be made by the tenant to establish the business
  • Corresponding reduction in costs to GLA in estates management costs (for security and maintenance of site)
  • The social and economic benefits of activating the site whilst the wider regeneration of the site by TSP is underway

In relation to the response to MGLA100726-3578, I have noted that there is an error in our response. "The information not held" was in relation to part 6 of that request. The exemption applied in that instance to part 5 of that request. I will amend our original response and reissue. 

Therefore, in relation to your request (annual rent, turnover rent, actual payments received, lease term and break provisions), as per our response in request MGLA090126-1628, this information concerns a commercial agreement between two parties for the use of land involving significant financial investment across a variety of creative activities, including film production, cultural events, brand experiences and corporate events. 

2. Confidentiality is provided by law. 

The information is subject to the common law duty of confidentiality. It is neither trivial nor publicly available. The rent and turnover rent figures constitute commercially sensitive financial information. Similarly, the lease term and break provisions form part of a negotiated commercial strategy with the GLA, and disclosure would reveal the operator's security of tenure, its long-term investment horizon, flexibility to exit, and negotiating position in future property transactions. It is also the case that disclosure may impair the GLA’s ability to negotiate other meanwhile uses on its land portfolio.

These conditions have been reached on the understanding that this information would remain confidential. 

3. The confidentiality is protecting a legitimate economic interest. 

To determine whether confidentiality protects a legitimate interest, the GLA consulted the third parties, who confirmed that disclosure would, on the balance of probabilities, cause commercial harm. Revealing the rent, turnover rent, lease term and break provisions would expose financial arrangements and negotiated strategic positions that are not publicly available. When viewed alongside information already in the public domain, this would disclose Broadwick’s timing, flexibility and risk appetite in relation to the premises, thereby prejudicing their commercial interests and weakening their competitive position in current or future negotiations. 

To confirm the rental terms are not publicly available, they remain confidential between landlord and tenant; and disclosure would be contrary to the expectations under which negotiations occurred.

4. The confidentiality would be adversely affected by disclosure. 

Disclosure of the information would inevitably harm the confidential nature of it and therefore the exemption at Regulation 12(5)(e) is engaged in respect of disclosure of the redacted information. 

Public interest 

Having carefully considered the competing public interests, the GLA recognises the significant public interest in transparency regarding the management of public land, scrutiny of leasing arrangements entered into by public bodies, and accountability for achieving best value. We have also considered the requester's submissions regarding the absence of a competitive tender process and the existence of exclusivity provisions within the leases.

However, we consider that disclosure of the withheld information, namely the rent, turnover rent, lease term, break provisions and financial payment information associated with the leases, would adversely affect the confidentiality of commercially sensitive information and would be likely to prejudice both the tenant's and the GLA's commercial interests. Disclosure would reveal detailed financial and strategic terms that remain current and which could reasonably be used by counterparties in future negotiations involving either party.

On balance, we have concluded that the public interest in maintaining the exception at regulation 12(5)(e) outweighs the public interest in disclosure.

Need a document on this page in an accessible format?

If you use assistive technology (such as a screen reader) and need a version of a PDF or other document on this page in a more accessible format, please get in touch via our online form and tell us which format you need.

It will also help us if you tell us which assistive technology you use. We’ll consider your request and get back to you in 5 working days.