DD1449 Award of Catering and Hospitality Contract to OCS

Type of decision: 
Director's decision
Code: 
DD1449
Date signed: 
03 February 2016
Decision by: 
Martin Clarke, Executive Director, Resources

Executive summary

Permission was given under MD1300 to procure a catering and hospitality contract as part of a wider TfL catering exercise.  However, the TfL procurement has been delayed, therefore the Authority carried out a separate competitive tender; this was necessary due to the current contract expiring within a year.

As the duration of the catering contract is no longer co-dependent on other parts of the GLA Group, the opportunity was taken to revisit the specification, terms and conditions.  The contract duration has been coordinated with the City Hall building lease, giving an initial term of 6 years in line with the break clause and then optional extensions of up to a further 5 years. This also gives the Authority the opportunity to gain necessary investment into the catering facilities in return for longer contract duration.

 

Decision

The Executive Director approves the appointment of OCS Group UK Limited as the catering and hospitality supplier to the GLA for the duration of 6 years, with optional extensions of up to a further 5 years, to a maximum total duration of 11 years.

 

Part 1: Non-confidential facts and advice

Introduction and background

The long term procurement strategy for the provision of outsourced Facilities Management services at the Greater London Authority’s core properties (City Hall, Trafalgar Square and Parliament Square Garden) was agreed under MD1300 in January 2014.

The procurement strategy included a plan for catering and hospitality services to be procured as a lot under the wider Transport for London catering opportunity.  In order to match the terms set for the TfL contract, it was agreed that the GLA contract would be let for the same duration, which was for 5 years, with an optional extension of a further 2 years.

Due to a change in strategy the TfL procurement has been delayed.  However, as the existing GLA contract for catering services has been extended for the maximum number of times, it was necessary for us to continue with a tender separately from the rest of the group.

As this tender was not dependent on contract requirements across other parts of the GLA group, it gave an opportunity to revisit the requisites, including the duration of the contract.  It was felt that it would be appropriate to tie the contract in to the remaining duration of the City hall lease.  Therefore, a contract principal term of 6 years would match the break clause in the lease, while further optional extensions of up to 5 years, would coincide with the full lease term.

Further to this, as part of the tender exercise we have asked for a substantial investment by the supplier.  In order to gain the best investment offers from the market place, it was important that we offered a suitable term in which the contractor would have sufficient time to recoup their initial costs.

As stated in Section 4 below, prior to the tender process commencing, a supplier engagement event was held at City Hall to discuss the opportunity with the market place and to determine the best procurement route and strategy to suit the Authority and suppliers needs, whilst maximising the number of interested suppliers. 

This procurement falls under the Public Contracts Regulations 2015, which requires certain procedures to be followed. This tender was advertised in the Official Journal of the European Community and also published on Compete For and Contracts Finder, websites well known to the market. 

A total of 23 suppliers initially expressed an interest in this tender, and three companies submitted bids. TfL Procurement undertook feedback for suppliers that did not submit a tender and reasons suppliers gave included lack of capacity and the scope of the services the Authority required.

A rigorous two-part process was undertaken which included evaluating commercial and technical expertise along with a commercial pricing element. Only OCS Group UK Limited, passed the commercial and technical part of the process and progressed to Stage 2. This stage included a practical catering assessment, pricing evaluation and outcomes which OCS successfully passed. The two unsuccessful suppliers’ prices were reviewed against OCS Group UK Limited prices to ensure OCS Group UK Limited prices were comparable and offered best value for money.

 

Objectives and expected outcomes

Permission is sought to award the contract to OCS UK Group Limited for the duration of 6 years, with an optional extensions of up to 5 years.

The contract will ‘go live’ in August 2016.  As the incumbent supplier they will benefit from an extended mobilisation period, during which time we will agree the investment strategy and timeline for refurbishing the catering facilities at all sites.

 

Equality comments

The procurement strategy for catering services ensures that equalities are taken into account when letting this contract.  In accordance with the specification, the supplier shall ensure that equalities issues are embedded throughout the contract, including all dietary requirements, payment of the London Living Wage and any other requirements that the Authority may have.

Further to this, the investment strategy for refurbishing the cafe will ensure that it remains fully accessible for all users.

 

Other considerations

Key Risks

The current contract is set to expire in July 2016.  If the new contract is not agreed it will be necessary for the Authority to begin another tender exercise.  As a full OJEU exercise takes approximately 12 to 18 months to carry out successfully we will not have enough time to complete the tender and so run the risk of losing the service entirely for a period of time.  This will affect the cafes in City Hall and Trafalgar Square as well as our ability to hold functions with the buildings.

Further to this, if we let the contract for a shorter term, we will not be able to attract the level of investment needed for the service to run successfully and so the risk will be that either suppliers will refuse to bid or we will have contractors carrying out a reduced service for the Authority.

Links to Mayoral Strategies

The provision of efficient and effective facilities management services at its core properties are critical to the proper operation of the GLA as an organisation, and Catering services are a key function for the Authority. Therefore effective catering and hospitality services help support the Mayor in delivering his strategy for London.  

The catering service supports the Mayor’s Food Strategy and the providers will lead the way in setting standards for large organisations in sustainable food procurement.  This will enable all users of the facilities to eat healthier and more environmentally sustainable food produced to high welfare standards.

In addition, the Service Provider will work with the Authority to comply with ISO20121 throughout its premises.

Consultations

The procurement strategy paper was presented to the TfL Procurement Board in July 2015.  The paper was agreed by Alex Fleming, Simon Grinter and Martin Clarke at the GLA and Jay Gami, Paul Plummer and David Young at TfL.

The procurement board agreed with the terms set out in the paper for the procurement of catering services at the GLA, including the duration of the contract.

A supplier engagement event was held by the Authority in May 2015 to seek views from the market place about the proposed contract.  This included questions around viability, maintaining a fully commercial contract, investment opportunities and the expected duration.  The feedback received indicated that for a substantial investment a supplier would expect a minimum term of 6 years. 

It is not considered necessary or appropriate to ‘consult’ within the meaning of Section 32 of the Greater London Authority Act as these arrangements relate to the Authority’s procurement of support services.

 

Financial comments

There are no direct costs associated with the provision of the catering and hospitality services at City Hall, Trafalgar Square and Parliament Square Garden; any ad hoc expenditure will be contained within individual Directorate’s approved hospitality and catering budget provision.

The new contract will commence from August 2016 to July 2022, with an option to extend for a further 5 years in 2 year lots.