Cleaning up London’s toxic air
Closed
672 Londoners have responded | 25/10/2021 - 19/07/2023
Discussions
Sunday 22 September 2019 was World Car Free Day. A large area of central London was closed off for free, outdoor activities and many boroughs were organising activities too. Londoners could request a Play Street from their local council, and close their streets for their own community events.
Did you take part in Car Free Day this year, why or why not? What was your experience? And did you apply for a Play Street?
Tell us more in the discussion below. Log in or sign up to take part.
The discussion ran from 20 June 2019 - 20 September 2019
Closed
Community guidelines
Anything you publish will appear almost right away. We want anyone to feel welcome to get involved in a constructive way. Our community guidelines will help us all do this.
Read our guidelines
Want to join our next discussion?
New here? Join Talk London, City Hall's online community where you can have your say on London's biggest issues.
Join Talk LondonAlready have an account?
Log into your accountNickPretzel
Community Member 6 years agoI've been cycling in London since 1979 and haven't driven a car since 1983! Back then cycling was a lot more dangerous than it is now. There were no cycle lanes to speak of, cars were much less aware of cyclists and far less used to seeing...
Show full commentI've been cycling in London since 1979 and haven't driven a car since 1983! Back then cycling was a lot more dangerous than it is now. There were no cycle lanes to speak of, cars were much less aware of cyclists and far less used to seeing them and navigating the roundabout at Hyde Park Corner was a hair raising experience. Things have improved beyond recognition. However, I am dismayed by the behaviour of a fair proportion of cyclists. They flaunt traffic regulations, are inconsiderate and rude and have a holier than thou attitude just because they're not in a car. While I don't drive anymore, I still need the use of one occasionally, mostly to transport bulky and heavy equipment. I believe we should treat all other road users with respect and courtesy. If we don't we can't expect to be treated likewise. Not only are those cyclists doing themselves a disservice, they're also tarnishing the reputation of those of us that do ride considerately. We end up all being tarnished by the same brush. Is like to see much greater enforcement of warnings and fines for consistent offenders for all road users that behave badly. That includes drivers using their mobiles as well as cyclists that ride recklessly.
Perhaps that's a little off topic, but I felt it needed saying. Car free days are a great idea and I would like to see more of them. A discussion group of cyclists, pedestrians and motorists might also prove useful and help us understand each others' complaints and needs and thus, hopefully, promote better behaviour and understanding between all road users.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoI don't think it is off topic at all. When I was young I had to do road safety classes and was taught about safety gear, lighting, signalling and how to ride a bike safely on the road before I was allowed to cycle to school - it was only a...
Show full commentI don't think it is off topic at all. When I was young I had to do road safety classes and was taught about safety gear, lighting, signalling and how to ride a bike safely on the road before I was allowed to cycle to school - it was only a short course spread over a week and I think I got a sticker or badge for my bike to prove I'd done it. I also remember we used to see public information films about road hazards and how to drive, cycle and cross roads safely on TV all the time. Does any of this still happen? if not, should there be a national media campaign to raise awareness of the basic rules and dangers again? I'd recommend a modern take on them to highlight the sheer and utter lunacy of driving/cycling/walking with eyes glued to a mobile phone, or isolating yourself from the world by wearing headphones when you're on or anywhere near a road.
Show less of commentSomeone
Community Member 6 years agoThey flaunt traffic regulations, are inconsiderate and rude
So a bit like a lot of other road users then?
I believe we should treat all other road users with respect and courtesy. If we don't we can't expect to be treated likewise.
I'd...
Show full commentThey flaunt traffic regulations, are inconsiderate and rude
So a bit like a lot of other road users then?
I believe we should treat all other road users with respect and courtesy. If we don't we can't expect to be treated likewise.
I'd like to be treated with respect and courtesy regardless of what other people do. Too many people seem to think it's OK to blame everyone for the sins of a few. A car free day would be a welcome relief.
Show less of commentSusan Cartwright
Community Member 6 years agoGood idea in principle but please remember people with mobility difficulties who need to get around. We're not all classified as disabled but can't walk far or cycle. For people like this we would be trapped indoors while you're having...
Show full commentGood idea in principle but please remember people with mobility difficulties who need to get around. We're not all classified as disabled but can't walk far or cycle. For people like this we would be trapped indoors while you're having fun in the streets.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoUnless it goes hand in hand with cheaper public transport and double down on buses this will be another reckless idea. Public transport is already at full capacity... this ain’t feasible.
You take car off the streets by improving public...
Show full commentUnless it goes hand in hand with cheaper public transport and double down on buses this will be another reckless idea. Public transport is already at full capacity... this ain’t feasible.
You take car off the streets by improving public transport and subsidising it properly... it’s not rocket science .....
Show less of commentTalk London
Official Representative 6 years agoHi everyone. We’re reading all your comments and are sharing them with our policy teams.
Will Norman, London’s Walking and Cycling Commissioner, wanted to add this message too:
“It’s great to see so many reactions to the announcement of our plans for Car Free Day. Thank you to everyone who took part and shared their ideas and suggestions.
Some of you have asked why London hasn’t organise a large, central car free event before. We already host many car free events in central London during the year, such as New Year’s Eve and Lumiere, the London Marathon and Ride London and we know that these have a positive impact on air quality while they are taking place. The Mayor recognises the value of a standalone event as part of World Car Free Day which is why this year we will be holding Reimagine, a major car free event in London
I wanted to stress that the events on the 22nd of September aren’t about banning Londoners from driving, but about offering an opportunity to celebrate a different use of our streets and help people to reimagine how street space can be used in alternative, healthier and more sustainable ways. The Mayor’s Transport Strategy (published in March 2018) aims to support more people in London to travel on foot, by cycle or using public transport wherever that is possible. Car Free Day will enable all of us to see the city from a different perspective."
Talk London
Official Representative 6 years agoMany of you have raised concerns about accessibility on Car Free Day, thank you for sharing this with us.
Our colleagues in the Transport Team told us that: “Car Free Day is for everyone. Access for disabled people is at the heart of TfL’s event planning and we will share information on how everyone can enjoy the day well in advance of the event. Buses will run through the centre of the event area, taxi drop off zones will be available to access the event and there will be activities for people of all ages and abilities to participate and enjoy.”
Talk London
sl638e
Community Member 6 years agoFantastic idea - a great way to make a real statement that our love affair with the car is over.
For my parents ‘ generation the car symbolised freedom and self-expression. They fulfilled their dreams, driving all over Europe, as well as...
Show full commentFantastic idea - a great way to make a real statement that our love affair with the car is over.
For my parents ‘ generation the car symbolised freedom and self-expression. They fulfilled their dreams, driving all over Europe, as well as enjoying an easier commute.
But nowadays driving is more of a nightmare. Motorists are stuck in interminable jams, stressed and frustrated, unfit and overweight. And worst of all they are belching out toxic gases that silently kill tens of thousands of people every year.
Our towns and cities are blighted by incessant traffic. High streets are dying because nobody will walk across dangerous, noisy, smelly roads to reach them.
It’s time to make a bold statement that the era of the car as the default choice is over. Many younger people are turning away from car ownership, but for those who’ve grown up loving cars it may take time.
I absolutely accept that for some the car is essential. I own one myself, for use when necessary. It’s nearly 20 years old, carefully maintained, and I use it once or twice a month. Whenever possible I walk or use public transport. I’m nobody special - many people in London could do what I do. It just takes a little thought and care.
Hopefully this car-free day will make people think and care a little more about the health and well-being of everyone and our city’s future.
Show less of commentmsn.com
Community Member 6 years agoSo pleased to read erudite comment by (Fred242 | Community Member | 1 hour ago). A permanent reduction in motorised traffic on our roads would be the best option. We would benefit from is a car free month of September rather than one car...
Show full commentSo pleased to read erudite comment by (Fred242 | Community Member | 1 hour ago). A permanent reduction in motorised traffic on our roads would be the best option. We would benefit from is a car free month of September rather than one car free day at the very least several days per week. The increased demand may help speed up improvements to the public transport system.
Show less of commentLorena Corneille
Community Member 6 years agoCar free day: The best new which we've all waited for sooo long.
Just been able to walk in the street with no traffic around and been able to open the windows will be a fantastic experience which I hope will be repeated more often.
Show full commentCar free day: The best new which we've all waited for sooo long.
Just been able to walk in the street with no traffic around and been able to open the windows will be a fantastic experience which I hope will be repeated more often.
Show less of commentGreg becker
Community Member 6 years agoA car free day is a great idea, a car free city centre is an even better idea.
Show full commentA car free day is a great idea, a car free city centre is an even better idea.
Show less of commentDamian Aune
Community Member 6 years agoI'll probably walk the dog, in the park, where there are no cars anyway, as usual. Has any thought been given to disabled people who have to rely on vehicles everytime they leave their home it will be because their choice has been removed...
Show full commentI'll probably walk the dog, in the park, where there are no cars anyway, as usual. Has any thought been given to disabled people who have to rely on vehicles everytime they leave their home it will be because their choice has been removed. I guess they can consider themselves sentenced to another day staying at home then.
Show less of commentFred242
Community Member 6 years agoAll well and good, I commute by bike daily myself. BUT I am getting really fed up with this constant attempt to demonize the car and also the motorbike. The cycle superhighways are appalling, much more dangerous to use than ordinary roads...
Show full commentAll well and good, I commute by bike daily myself. BUT I am getting really fed up with this constant attempt to demonize the car and also the motorbike. The cycle superhighways are appalling, much more dangerous to use than ordinary roads because you are stuck with all the Mamils and the brain dead Borisbikers, at least on the road you are not enclosed in a sort of virtual fight cage with them. Let's have some sensible back road routes- much more pleasant anyway and get rid of all these vanity projects by the Mayor. They only cause huge traffic disruption and resentment by the 85% of road users who will never cycle.
Show less of commentSomeone
Community Member 6 years agoFred, those tracks make cycling possible for anyone who wishes to do it, and it seems that they don't cause disruption once built. But they only work if they are actually designed for cycling on. The back road routes you ask for are still...
Show full commentFred, those tracks make cycling possible for anyone who wishes to do it, and it seems that they don't cause disruption once built. But they only work if they are actually designed for cycling on. The back road routes you ask for are still used by rat runners, so are no good for most people. They are a half-hearted and ineffective compromise. If you really do cycle in motor traffic, you are one of the small minority willing to do so. And if you prefer cycling in the carriageway you are free to carry on.
Show less of commentPaul263
Community Member 6 years agoSo wheelchair users are barred from London on 22nd September? What about the congestion this will create outside the "car free zone"? Does the pollution there not matter? You keep prattling on about air quality.
So wheelchair users are barred from London on 22nd September? What about the congestion this will create outside the "car free zone"? Does the pollution there not matter? You keep prattling on about air quality.
charlesh9
Community Member 6 years agoThe city going car free is not the answer and so I will not be partaking. I believe that the majority of people in the UK, like me, use and depend on cars. The problems that are being attributed to cars will not be solved by getting rid of...
Show full commentThe city going car free is not the answer and so I will not be partaking. I believe that the majority of people in the UK, like me, use and depend on cars. The problems that are being attributed to cars will not be solved by getting rid of them. The transport of the future wil be mainly cars, albeit manufactured to reduce some of the problems old cars had such as energy use and emissions and being driven by humans. The attributed problems are much more relevant for such things as big technology, smart phones, tablets, computers and the like. We don't talk about a city going smart phone free?
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agowouldn't be amazing to also remove all the cars from the parking spots as well!
there will be so much more space for people!!!!
Show full commentwouldn't be amazing to also remove all the cars from the parking spots as well!
there will be so much more space for people!!!!
Show less of commentwoolwich10
Community Member 6 years agoI like the idea, but overall we need to move much quicker with ideas to help people buy/exchange for electric cars to stop the issue at source.
London is full of little corners of land that a pretty dirty and seemingly abandoned, why not...
Show full commentI like the idea, but overall we need to move much quicker with ideas to help people buy/exchange for electric cars to stop the issue at source.
London is full of little corners of land that a pretty dirty and seemingly abandoned, why not fill then will trees and plants to help clean the air.
Show less of commentjenjohnmartin
Community Member 6 years agoExcellent idea, all designated bicycle routes throughout London should be car free
Show full commentExcellent idea, all designated bicycle routes throughout London should be car free
Show less of commentSomeone
Community Member 6 years agoIt's remarkable how many drivers object to any limit to their right to poison people. Even a few hours on a few streets on one single day is too much for them to bear, whatever the benefits to others. I wonder how many deaths it would take...
Show full commentIt's remarkable how many drivers object to any limit to their right to poison people. Even a few hours on a few streets on one single day is too much for them to bear, whatever the benefits to others. I wonder how many deaths it would take to get them to change.
I think this idea is a positive step, even if long overdue, and lacking ambition.. People will see the damage that motor traffic causes. Perhaps it will lead to more action.
Show less of commentMazwells
Community Member 6 years agoSilly idea and waste of resources required for organising this event.
Show full commentSilly idea and waste of resources required for organising this event.
Show less of commentTooting resident
Community Member 6 years agoI agree with Ben. It is not only those who qualify for blue badges who are dependent on their cars. People may also need to use their cars in an emergency, for instance to take a sick child to hospital. Certain key routes and roads must...
Show full commentI agree with Ben. It is not only those who qualify for blue badges who are dependent on their cars. People may also need to use their cars in an emergency, for instance to take a sick child to hospital. Certain key routes and roads must be kept open.
Show less of commentGraemeM
Community Member 6 years agoI would like to see a Cyclists Free day - every day.
Show full commentI would like to see a Cyclists Free day - every day.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoAs said below, many disabled people can't use buses, let alone bikes, but do nto qualify for Blue Badges - so what do they do?
Redwayk | Community Member | 2 min ago
I agree with the previous comment. Disabled people, like myself and my...
Show full commentAs said below, many disabled people can't use buses, let alone bikes, but do nto qualify for Blue Badges - so what do they do?
Redwayk | Community Member | 2 min ago
I agree with the previous comment. Disabled people, like myself and my wife, are often ignored, or forgotten, in all the anti-car rhetoric and the clamour about cycling and walking.
Show less of comment