Brexit: the negotiation process

User Image for
Added by Talk London

In response to the government White Paper: The United Kingdom’s exit from and new partnership with the European Union, the Mayor released a paper entitled "London's Global and European Future"

In this the Mayor responded to the twelve priorities in the government’s White Paper on Brexit, focussing on issues affecting the capital. The main elements of the Mayor’s response are:
- A call for a guarantee that all EU citizens presently living in the UK can stay post Brexit
- That there needs to be an interim trade agreement that ensures current market access arrangements are retained during the negotiations, if they last longer than two years, until the UK’s future relationship with the EU is finalised
- That we need to retain, or better, the current EU environmental regulations that benefit London
- That more clarity is needed around possible future immigration policy, and London needs the ability to determine how much immigration it should receive if the government can’t guarantee the levels necessary for its economy
- That there should be increased devolution of fiscal powers to London, to help the capital respond to the challenges of Brexit
- That we need effective data and intelligence sharing arrangements with European Union member states to detect and prevent crime and terrorism

What do you think of this approach? Do you think there are other issues that should be raised with central government to secure the best deal for London?

The discussion ran from 15 March 2017 - 15 June 2017

Closed


Want to join our next discussion?

New here? Join Talk London, City Hall's online community where you can have your say on London's biggest issues.

Join Talk London

Already have an account?

Log into your account
Comments (148)

Avatar for -

It staggers me the posters who believe in democracy when it agrees with their views. There was a referendum, the country voted to leave, the Parliamentary procedure has been followed and notice is to be shortly formerly given. There will...

Show full comment

It staggers me the posters who believe in democracy when it agrees with their views. There was a referendum, the country voted to leave, the Parliamentary procedure has been followed and notice is to be shortly formerly given. There will not be a new vote, there will not be a change of policy because some people disagree. It would be productive to look how London and the UK can get the best outlook and be best prepared to take advantage. It is so pointless pretending Brexit will not happen. By,focusing on the past and living in demial you ignore the opportunities available for today and tomorrow. Lomdon needs to clean up the pollution, get rid of diesels, improve roads to minimize congestion and separate bicycle, pedestrian and motorized traffic. London needs integrated public Transport. Maybe Eurostar should come under TfL as it is a London Service. London needs affordable housing, London needs to protect those who are made self employed on zero hours contracts and who have lost the employment rights they had in the days before the EU when Unions were stronger. Tuere is so much to be done to make London better none of which are achieved by saying I do not like it so it is not democratic. How are we going to make London relevant to people from Africa, Asia, Australasia, the Americas? The world is not all White European, why do people want to ignore everyone else?

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

Agree100%. Couldn't have said it better myself.

Avatar for - Adelie penguin

"It staggers me the posters who believe in democracy when it agrees with their views." Funny, I thought that described the Brexiters perfectly right there. People can still criticize despite your thin majority referendum - that's the part...

Show full comment

"It staggers me the posters who believe in democracy when it agrees with their views." Funny, I thought that described the Brexiters perfectly right there. People can still criticize despite your thin majority referendum - that's the part of democracy under threat right now.

I fail to see how removing a safeguard for human rights in the form of the EU will help to accomplish any of the improvement goals for London. These are precisely the kinds of things conservative governments are known to actively sabotage.

Show less of comment

Load more
Avatar for - Adelie penguin

Too many people in this thread fail to realize that "democracy" does not mean blindly following along with an obviously destructive goal just because a thin majority voted for it once, in a referendum full of conscious misinformation no...

Show full comment

Too many people in this thread fail to realize that "democracy" does not mean blindly following along with an obviously destructive goal just because a thin majority voted for it once, in a referendum full of conscious misinformation no less. If you're going to use democracy in your argument then that also means the other side bring able to criticize what you're doing. There are many legitimate reasons to oppose Brexit and we are not going to simply shut up just because xenophonia is now the new normal in this country. To me it's a raging disappointment that that's what this country now stands for and obviously I'm not alone in this outlook.

Brexiters name-calling and bullying people into silence does absolutely nothing to convince me they have a genuine cause.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

The democratic vote to leave was our own Declaration of Independence. The sooner we are able to exit the European Empire, the better.

Avatar for -

Well said Ian!

Avatar for - Orangutan

Brexit is here. Mainly due to the weak Conservative previous Prime minister.
The media are fuelling all kinds of crisis. Our negotiators will try and get the best deal but it will not please everyone, especially politicians who prefer to...

Show full comment

Brexit is here. Mainly due to the weak Conservative previous Prime minister.
The media are fuelling all kinds of crisis. Our negotiators will try and get the best deal but it will not please everyone, especially politicians who prefer to score points rather than help run our country.
There can be no fail safe plan. If Brussels and UK cannot agree then we go back and re-negotiate not walk away as some have suggested. As far as immigration is concerned people can apply for jobs here by work permit and we do the same if we wish to work in the Europe. People from anywhere outside our country have to be monitored.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

Brexit is here mainly because WE who voted leave put enough pressure on the government to get a referendum. After all, we don't live in a totalitarian state, so the government can't ignore us forever.

Show full comment

Brexit is here mainly because WE who voted leave put enough pressure on the government to get a referendum. After all, we don't live in a totalitarian state, so the government can't ignore us forever.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

I too call on the Mayor to urge Parliament to amend the "great repeal bill" in the summer to provide for a referendum on the terms of Brexit with the option to Remain.

London voted to Remain, not for the Mayor to campaign for a better...

Show full comment

I too call on the Mayor to urge Parliament to amend the "great repeal bill" in the summer to provide for a referendum on the terms of Brexit with the option to Remain.

London voted to Remain, not for the Mayor to campaign for a better Brexit.

The argument for the Referendum on the terms is simple project management. No-one takes a project from idea to implementation without a project review. In June, Leave had no plan. Every Leave voter decided for themselves what Brexit meant. The June vote conveyed a valid democratic mandate. But that mandate is provisional until there is a plan. Only when there is a defined plan whose benefits costs and risks can be properly assessed can there be a final decision.

The referendum on the terms would not be a re-run of June. It would be asking a quite different question. Instead of "choose your own Brexit" the choice would be between Theresa May's Brexit and Remain.

Leave voters who argue against a referendum on the terms on the ground that there has been a vote need to understand the provisional nature of a decision made without all the facts. I once decided to go somewhere on holiday. When I looked at the flights they were too expensive. Leave voters would tell me that I had to go anyway because that decision had been made. But I did not go there. I revised my intentions in the light of new information. The earlier plan was abandoned. No matter, absent all the facts it had only been a provisional decision.

You can read more from me on this subject on my Facebook page: Campaign for the Real Referendum - on the Terms of Brexit.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

There's one big flaw in your argument: when you changed your holiday plans, YOU made the decision, but THE PEOPLE would decide in a second referendum and they might vote exactly the same as before.

Show full comment

There's one big flaw in your argument: when you changed your holiday plans, YOU made the decision, but THE PEOPLE would decide in a second referendum and they might vote exactly the same as before.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

London's legimate concerns over the effects of Brexit will be managed by the Govement and Mrs May have no fear. But to somehow links London's fate with that of Scotland is naive, Ms Sturgeon is ridiculous in her assertion that Scotland's...

Show full comment

London's legimate concerns over the effects of Brexit will be managed by the Govement and Mrs May have no fear. But to somehow links London's fate with that of Scotland is naive, Ms Sturgeon is ridiculous in her assertion that Scotland's interests are best served by leaving the union. Scotland would plunge itself into being a third world country which we no doubt would have to bail out.

- Scots would have no right to work in England without getting a job and securing a visa over other competing foreign countries.
- Scotland's trade is 50% with the UK and they would no longer have a single market within the Union
- they would get the Euro
- they would have no access to the 17% on income generated by the City of London
- they would have a 17 billion hole in there curretn account
- the Barnett formula would cease.
- they would get a proportionate share of the UK's national deficit.
- they would need to create all their organs of state, tax office, DVLA, etc etc

Ms Sturgeon does not have the interests of Scotland first but places her narrow desire for power above all.

We really are disproportionate in spending anytime talking about Scotland with its small population and contribution to the British economy.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

Nicola Sturgeon doesn't seem too keen on respecting the will of the people. A bit like some people posting on this forum...

Avatar for -

Firstly who asked this Mayor to repond to the white paper, I would suggest he needs to get on with the day job of looking after the day to day needs of Londoners rather than raising his profile for his next polical appointment.

Secondly...

Show full comment

Firstly who asked this Mayor to repond to the white paper, I would suggest he needs to get on with the day job of looking after the day to day needs of Londoners rather than raising his profile for his next polical appointment.

Secondly, why an earth should we take the slightest notice of a politician who lied in his manifesto to get elected, we all remember the lies over tube fare rises and 50% affordable houses. I would politely suggest he goes and crawls back under the rock from whence he came.

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Orangutan

Yep. Couldn't agree more.

Avatar for -
Avatar for -

Scotland voted remain and they are trying to remain by seeking to leave the Union. I don't think their economy is strong enough to make that feasible but if London - which also voted remain - joined them.....

Avatar for -

That would do it. Lets face it, it's the wealth generated by London that subsidises a lot of the UK, Scotland would be less of a drain on us.

Avatar for - Adelie penguin

Honestly I'd like to see the Brexit parts of England going it alone, instead of dragging London and Scotland down with their awful decisions. They wouldn't last a day and that's why they're so against Scottish or even London independence.

Load more
Avatar for -

The Conservatives have moved to a much more right wing area of politics. I don't believe they have the country's or populations best interest at heart in perusing the exit. If they did they would have some sort of study together and had a...

Show full comment

The Conservatives have moved to a much more right wing area of politics. I don't believe they have the country's or populations best interest at heart in perusing the exit. If they did they would have some sort of study together and had a look at both the long and short term repercussions together. This would have given them an idea of how they would negotiate with the EU and they could have chosen a meeting and possibly discussed changes that might have benefitted everybody. Now we're being primed for a this harder than exit where we just walk away with nothing, no deal etc, and that's probably what will happen maybe before the end of the two years ...
All this for 1.8% of the population who maybe though we'll be able to stay within the Single Market, that Cornwall will keep it's EU money, that 350mill will be spent on the nhs, and finally that migration will be stopped. We've been sold a pup, the Emperor has no clothes but ones who could stop it see how they can benefit and so they're buying. Problem is it's us that will pick up the bill.
The opposition party is so divided it couldn't organise a sit down protest on a train, let alone spot a govt U-turn. They've already sold London out, they don't and won't represent the people who elected them.

Set against this The Mayor issues the above .... do you really think anybody will listen ?

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

Brexit is for the 52% - not sure where you got 1.8% from, EvilChicken0. Don't you respect democracy either?

Avatar for - Orangutan

Well said Alison

Avatar for - Staghorn coral

I agree with the first commenter Greg Tingey.
People seem to sleepwalking into a disaster, and probably will wish they had stayed in the EU when it is too late.
Mrs may tells Scotland to stay with England as we are there nearest and main...

Show full comment

I agree with the first commenter Greg Tingey.
People seem to sleepwalking into a disaster, and probably will wish they had stayed in the EU when it is too late.
Mrs may tells Scotland to stay with England as we are there nearest and main trading partner, while at the same time she is taking the UK away from its nearest and main trading partner. Daft.
Pity London's Mayor is not PM we might get some sense.

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Tiger

Are you mad sadiq khan as pm,,if you like living in a democracy accept the vote and move on ,oo much unchecked immigration is destroying our country and ou think khan will stop that

Avatar for -

I'd vote for that.

Load more
Avatar for -

NO the decision has been made so accept it. It can not come soon enough as far as I am concerned. The country including London is extremely overcrowded and British people are suffering due to the influx of terrorists, criminals and...

Show full comment

NO the decision has been made so accept it. It can not come soon enough as far as I am concerned. The country including London is extremely overcrowded and British people are suffering due to the influx of terrorists, criminals and unskilled illegal immigrants.I want my country back. I want to feel I am in England not Europe. If people move here they should learn to speak English and confirm to British culture but they don't.

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Tiger

Beat me to it ,well said

Show full comment

Beat me to it ,well said

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

Yes, I feel that the importance of culture and community has been destroyed by the ideology of free movement. People who come here ought to feel the need to fit in and get to know their neighbour, but sadly the EU has brought with it a...

Show full comment

Yes, I feel that the importance of culture and community has been destroyed by the ideology of free movement. People who come here ought to feel the need to fit in and get to know their neighbour, but sadly the EU has brought with it a sense of entitlement.

Show less of comment

Load more
Avatar for -

In the past few months I have been receiving the EU daily news. It is not clear how much of that is affected by UK input, but clearly we, the UK have contributed hugely and in many ways.
I do hope that we will retain commitment to most...

Show full comment

In the past few months I have been receiving the EU daily news. It is not clear how much of that is affected by UK input, but clearly we, the UK have contributed hugely and in many ways.
I do hope that we will retain commitment to most of the legislative improvements or exceeding them, especially the environmental ones that are contribute to the slowing of global warming and reducing the destruction of biodiversity.

London's situation will be affected in a major way if we were reduce UK standards on these things.

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Staghorn coral

On top of the priorities highlighted by the Mayor, I would add an agreement for the top Universities in London (UCL, KCL, LSE, Imperial) to retain the pool of European talent in research and students. Also an agreement for these...

Show full comment

On top of the priorities highlighted by the Mayor, I would add an agreement for the top Universities in London (UCL, KCL, LSE, Imperial) to retain the pool of European talent in research and students. Also an agreement for these Universities that would allow them to take part in European Consortiums for Research (Horizon 2020, for instance).

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

The sooner we get on with getting OUT the better...

Avatar for -

How exactly ?

Avatar for - Orangutan

Well said Mediaman. Lets make Britain Great again

Load more
Avatar for -

I think this list is too exclusive. London needs to ensure it can get the best talent from around the world and ensure the best standards worldwide and unfettered acess to service and trade markets globally. Ignoring the non "White European...

Show full comment

I think this list is too exclusive. London needs to ensure it can get the best talent from around the world and ensure the best standards worldwide and unfettered acess to service and trade markets globally. Ignoring the non "White European" areas of the world is not in Lomdon's interest.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

In my opinion...the only EU citizens currently living in the UK who should be entitled to stay are those who have a legitimate job and those who are married/living with and/or have a child by a British citizen. Pointless allowing thousands...

Show full comment

In my opinion...the only EU citizens currently living in the UK who should be entitled to stay are those who have a legitimate job and those who are married/living with and/or have a child by a British citizen. Pointless allowing thousands of out of work European citizens to continue to live in the UK....and those who do remain need a visa in ALL cases. Any child/marriage/job should be confirmed prior to issue. In addition, any immigration policy should be for the whole of the UK and not exclude London. London is packed to capacity...Khan should be concentrating his efforts on making London a better, safer place for those who already live in it before he opens his arms to more foreign workers that we apparently "need".

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Tiger

Totally agree

Avatar for -

If jobs go abroad, all those unemployed immigrants will go with them. Then we'll have more housing available - and a seat on the tube.

Load more
Avatar for - Orangutan

Just what I would have expected from the worse Mayor ever. Shame we don't have one that lives in the real world.

Avatar for - Tiger

Spot on gazbag

Avatar for - Monarch butterfly

I agree with Greg Tingey, but perhaps to make sure, we should suggest that Brexit should be cancelled

I am sorry to have to say this, but in my view, triggering A50 will be one of the most asinine and stupid things that this Government...

Show full comment

I agree with Greg Tingey, but perhaps to make sure, we should suggest that Brexit should be cancelled

I am sorry to have to say this, but in my view, triggering A50 will be one of the most asinine and stupid things that this Government has ever done, that is, apart from having the EU Referendum at all.

The recent White Paper stated that Parliament was always sovereign anyway - and the vast majority of EU laws that the UK subscribed to were pro-consumer, pro-ordinary worker and ensuring that big business did not overstep the mark.

Even if we leave the EU, there will still be immigration because there has been a skill shortage in the UK plus large companies will always keep costs down in any way they can. Also, most trade treaties with other countries have clauses about making it easier for their nationals to come to the UK. Nothing wrong with this in my book - but it is probably not what the average Brexiteer voted for! A latest report for the Lords states that ending free movement may not cut migration – see:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-39178288

The Leavers implemented Project Lie - ordinary people were not told that their problems were not because of EU policy, but because successive UK Governments, both Labour and Tory had allowed the current economic situation to materialise, including over-priced housing that keeps many young folks, who do not have access to the Bank of Mum & Dad, away from buying their own home.

We no longer have an indigenous ship building industry to speak of, we no longer have an indigenous car industry to speak of and we no longer have a UK aircraft building industry to speak of. Most of our utilities and railways are now franchised out, in many cases to European state-owned companies, who are laughing at us. Profits from these utilities go our European friends (and elsewhere of course) who are now subsidising their taxpayers, not ours. Former Business Secretary Sir Vince Cable expressed concerns about jobs because of the government's "lack of commitment to the customs union and the single market".
Sir Vince Cable stated:
“Car components have to go backwards and forwards across frontiers and they will acquire tariffs and checks. Vauxhall is particularly exposed to this, [as] about 80% of its exports are to the European Union. If you're a hard-headed car executive looking at the competitiveness of Britain versus German plants, Britain, I'm afraid, is going to slip down the ranking in future."
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-39175740

George Osborne warns against leaving EU without a trade deal:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-39116895

Many thousands of workers in the finance sector will move away from London, yet another own goal, because those finance workers also paid taxes and bought stuff whilst in the UK. One of Germany's most senior banking regulators has warned London that it is likely to lose its role as "the gateway to Europe" for vital financial services. Dr Andreas Dombret, executive board member for the German central bank, the Bundesbank, said that even if banking rules were "equivalent" between the UK and the rest of the European Union, that was "miles away from access to the single market".
Mr Dombret's comments were made at a private meeting of German businesses and banks organised by Boston Consulting Group in Frankfurt earlier this week.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-38925440

The UK still hangs on to tax havens - nothing whatsoever to do with the EU - and money deposited in those tax havens are largely exempt from tax, thus further decreasing money going into the UK Exchequer - which in turn means more cuts on the already poor.

To survive, the UK has to sell arms to Saudi Arabia and now Theresa May wants to sell arms to President Erdogan in Turkey, who will doubtless use them against the Kurds, who valiantly supported the UK against Daesh. Theresa May now has to - of yet another unsavoury character, namely the new neo-con POTUS, in order to try to sell whatever to the US. Our position as a trading nation will be made worse, not better, as a result of leaving the EU. Of course, we look to countries outside the EU to make trade deals with but, as an example, India says that a UK free trade deal will take years. India's finance minister has said that a free trade deal with Britain will take a "long time" and that no negotiations will start until the Brexit process has been completed.
On a visit to the UK today to meet the chancellor and the foreign secretary to discuss trade, Arun Jaitley, Minister of Finance of India, said there was "great enthusiasm" for a deal.
But he made it clear that any talks would have to run "in parallel" with current Indian negotiations with the European Union (EU). The EU and India launched free trade talks in 2007 but progress has been slow.
http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-39103078

Staying within the EU also means that around 27 countries are all trying to look collectively after each other to a great extent - leaving the EU means the UK pursues national interest only - how can this be better? When awarding the Nobel Peace Prize to the EU, the Norwegian Nobel Committee said its decision was based on the stabilising role the EU has played in transforming most of Europe from a continent of war to a continent of peace. The EU’s most important achievement, according to the committee, has been "the successful struggle for peace and reconciliation and for democracy and human rights". The work of the EU represents "fraternity between nations" and amounts to a form of the "peace congresses" cited by Alfred Nobel as criteria for the Peace Prize in his 1895 will.
https://europa.eu/european-union/about-eu/history/2010-today/2012/eu-no…

The EU Referendum was advisory and the vote was not large enough to justify going ahead. It is more patriotic to do what is best for the country - in particular, what is best for the JAMs (Just About Managing) and those below the JAMs who are not managing at all.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -

Very good summary. Thanks Lee.

Avatar for -

Finally some common sense - it's about time that the Brexiters get over their jingoism and back slapping see the situation for what it is.Great summary Lee

Show full comment

Finally some common sense - it's about time that the Brexiters get over their jingoism and back slapping see the situation for what it is.Great summary Lee

Show less of comment

Load more
Avatar for -

Start a serious campaign for a second referendum, so that we can stop this insanity, before it's too late!

Avatar for - Orangutan

Why would we want a second referendum. The country have voted and common sense won.

Show full comment

Why would we want a second referendum. The country have voted and common sense won.

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Tiger

AGREED lets move on

Load more