Cleaning up London’s toxic air
Closed
672 Londoners have responded | 25/10/2021 - 19/07/2023
Discussions
Sunday 22 September 2019 was World Car Free Day. A large area of central London was closed off for free, outdoor activities and many boroughs were organising activities too. Londoners could request a Play Street from their local council, and close their streets for their own community events.
Did you take part in Car Free Day this year, why or why not? What was your experience? And did you apply for a Play Street?
Tell us more in the discussion below. Log in or sign up to take part.
The discussion ran from 20 June 2019 - 20 September 2019
Closed
Community guidelines
Anything you publish will appear almost right away. We want anyone to feel welcome to get involved in a constructive way. Our community guidelines will help us all do this.
Read our guidelines
Want to join our next discussion?
New here? Join Talk London, City Hall's online community where you can have your say on London's biggest issues.
Join Talk LondonAlready have an account?
Log into your account1stworld city
Community Member 6 years agoSeveral years worth of Play Streets and street parties, both where cars are excluded and both which have wide use in this locvation, has generated an immensely, very welcome and rather envied (apparantly) sense of community in my own street...
Show full commentSeveral years worth of Play Streets and street parties, both where cars are excluded and both which have wide use in this locvation, has generated an immensely, very welcome and rather envied (apparantly) sense of community in my own street.
As well as the annual street party, last year was our first Car Free Day in acknowledgement of World Car Free Day in September. The enjoyment was immense and the relief from the daily grind of thousands of vehicles hammering up and down our residential street, our home, was so welcomed.
The benefits are much more to be found in getting to know who shares your part of London and building your own small community with knock on for crime awareness, neighbourliness, skill exchange, asset sharing and a whole lot more. We’ve seen them all and experience them all. Testimonials are many - people now know and are able to communicate with many, many others who live close to them, soemthing which didnt happen previosuly. There will be a high level of recommendation to give it a go in your own street from the vast majority of residents in this one.
Forget the inevitable beefs about cars fromsome; this one is a much bigger opportunity to experience.
What could the GLA do to assist:? Ensure fees are nil or nominal to residents; remove any Public Lability risk; have a FAQ / How-to available on a central web site; collect ideas on successful street event items, eg tug of war or perhaps the first “Wacky Race” we undertook in 2018, where anything goes, provided it goes.
Have some fun with it rather than a moan about it, just for once.
Show less of commentgmg57
Community Member 6 years agofunnily enough the are good communities without demonising cars. And no I am not a car driver.
Show full commentfunnily enough the are good communities without demonising cars. And no I am not a car driver.
Show less of commentFlower
Community Member 6 years agoI agree that it is a good idea in principle, but my daughter is one of the 1% who is a wheelchair user and lives and works in London. She works on Sundays and this will make her already very difficult commute even worse. It would be a...
Show full commentI agree that it is a good idea in principle, but my daughter is one of the 1% who is a wheelchair user and lives and works in London. She works on Sundays and this will make her already very difficult commute even worse. It would be a wonderful idea, if public transport was made fully accessible, then we could perhaps all truly get behind it. As it is, it leaves disabled people who already struggle to get about in London, with an even bigger struggle, even if it is only for one day a year. Some people can’t just hop on a bike or walk up the stairs of the tube! Maybe we should have one day a year where everyone was forced to get around London in a wheelchair, without standing up when accessibility is impossible, we may find people more willing to look at the transport infrastructure then!
Show less of commentRoutemaster
Community Member 6 years ago"every journey matters..." No it doesnt there is an imposed hierachy here of what the mayor condsiders acceptable. At least now he has come clean as anti-car and not disguised it by pretending its about congestion or poullution. I drive...
Show full comment"every journey matters..." No it doesnt there is an imposed hierachy here of what the mayor condsiders acceptable. At least now he has come clean as anti-car and not disguised it by pretending its about congestion or poullution. I drive an electric car but that isnt good enough it seems.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoEdwardsT | Community Member | 13 min ago
Report
The cycle lanes on the Embankment carry more people than all the adjacent motor lanes combined during peak hours. Outside peak hours, the motor lanes are quiet. The primary cause of...
Show full commentEdwardsT | Community Member | 13 min ago
Report
The cycle lanes on the Embankment carry more people than all the adjacent motor lanes combined during peak hours. Outside peak hours, the motor lanes are quiet. The primary cause of congestion along the Embankment is the same as on other roads - too many motor vehicles - and too many cars and taxis with only 1 person in them!
Nope, the cause of the increased congestion on the Embankment is that two lanes of traffic either way have been reduced to one either way. The "number of bicycles" counter near Embankment tube has about 600 a day when I've seen it. There are more cars and vans using that road every hour. Cycle lanes are a good thing, but not when they slow down other traffic causing extra pollution. The one on the Embankment should be scrapped and moved to side streets. I suppose the cyclist counter would show more if more of the cyclist actually bothered to use it.
We're not all fit and young enough to cycle.
Show less of commentgmg57
Community Member 6 years agoThe embankment cycle lanes also mean that emergency vehicles cannot get through. They are paved so there is no leeway for cars to move to allow them through. This is often the case on other roads as well. I walk along the embankment...
Show full commentThe embankment cycle lanes also mean that emergency vehicles cannot get through. They are paved so there is no leeway for cars to move to allow them through. This is often the case on other roads as well. I walk along the embankment frequently and often see cyclists not even using the cycle lanes. Can’t say I blame them though given the very aggressive nature of some of their fellow cyclists.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoI agree with Ben Beck's comment.
I have a Blue Badge and, because of my mobility limitations, I travel to central London by car every Sunday to attend church, where the services are in Welsh.
A car-free zone in central London on 22nd of...
Show full commentI agree with Ben Beck's comment.
I have a Blue Badge and, because of my mobility limitations, I travel to central London by car every Sunday to attend church, where the services are in Welsh.
A car-free zone in central London on 22nd of September will mean that I cannot do so. I think this is an infringement of my liberty to worship in my native language.
The progress in providing step-free public transport is far too slow.
EdwardsT
Community Member 6 years agoAt last!!! It's been a long time coming. But only 12 miles out of the total 360 miles of TfL's road network isn't hugely ambitious is it? I think we should be doing a lot more considering the Mayor of London has declared a climate emergency...
Show full commentAt last!!! It's been a long time coming. But only 12 miles out of the total 360 miles of TfL's road network isn't hugely ambitious is it? I think we should be doing a lot more considering the Mayor of London has declared a climate emergency (although you wouldn't know it with Silvertown Tunnel still going ahead!!!). A car free day is a great opportunity for people to see just how much nicer it is in London without cars and without having to rely on cars. It's a chance for people to seek alternatives to driving, such as cycling. Most car journeys are under 5 miles which is a distance easily cycled. However, without the adequate infrastructure in place I fear that a car free day will be just that - one day - and that those who drive will be back in their cars the day after. It is quality infrastructure that will ultimately give us the modal shift from car to bicycle which we so urgently require.
Show less of commentbrunomichela
Community Member 6 years agoIt would be great if public transports were free that day. You need to keep in mind that most people use their cars because it's the cheapest or the quickest way to travel in London. It's nice the idea just for a day, to rise the issue of...
Show full commentIt would be great if public transports were free that day. You need to keep in mind that most people use their cars because it's the cheapest or the quickest way to travel in London. It's nice the idea just for a day, to rise the issue of cars and pollution, but if you want to solve the problem of cars in general you must think of practicle alternative solutions. Public transports are outrageously expensive, trains especially. The tube is fine only if you want to reach central London but it's unpractical if you want to move between zones 4/5/6. Living without a car is possible only in zones 1 and 2, but London is far bigger than that.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoWhen will you get your heads round the idea that some vehicles do have to come into London, for deliveries, etc.? The bus lanes on, e.g., the Embankment have made pollution worse because they have slowed vehicular traffic down to a crawl.
Show full commentWhen will you get your heads round the idea that some vehicles do have to come into London, for deliveries, etc.? The bus lanes on, e.g., the Embankment have made pollution worse because they have slowed vehicular traffic down to a crawl.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoI mean cycle lanes!
Show full commentI mean cycle lanes!
Show less of commentEdwardsT
Community Member 6 years agoThe cycle lanes on the Embankment carry more people than all the adjacent motor lanes combined during peak hours. Outside peak hours, the motor lanes are quiet. The primary cause of congestion along the Embankment is the same as on other...
Show full commentThe cycle lanes on the Embankment carry more people than all the adjacent motor lanes combined during peak hours. Outside peak hours, the motor lanes are quiet. The primary cause of congestion along the Embankment is the same as on other roads - too many motor vehicles - and too many cars and taxis with only 1 person in them!
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoI'm up for car free day But the mayor should be doing more on policing Knife crime.I suppose all the areas will be full of Police who could be doing much better work. When will our Mayor wake up & do something positive for London my city
Show full commentI'm up for car free day But the mayor should be doing more on policing Knife crime.I suppose all the areas will be full of Police who could be doing much better work. When will our Mayor wake up & do something positive for London my city
Show less of commentEdwardsT
Community Member 6 years agoAgreed. I think the £1bn which is going to spent on the Silvertown motor vehicle tunnel should be spend on policing instead.
Show full commentAgreed. I think the £1bn which is going to spent on the Silvertown motor vehicle tunnel should be spend on policing instead.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoI can't wait for this. Get rid of all but strictly necessary cars, then maybe cyclists will feel brave enough to stop endangering pedestrians by riding on the pavement...
Show full commentI can't wait for this. Get rid of all but strictly necessary cars, then maybe cyclists will feel brave enough to stop endangering pedestrians by riding on the pavement...
Show less of commentEdwardsT
Community Member 6 years agoWhat a silly comment. Most car journeys are not necessary to do using a car. Most car journeys are under 5 miles (easily done by cycle!) and most car journeys are single occupancy. Bicycles (whether on the pavement or not) pose relatively...
Show full commentWhat a silly comment. Most car journeys are not necessary to do using a car. Most car journeys are under 5 miles (easily done by cycle!) and most car journeys are single occupancy. Bicycles (whether on the pavement or not) pose relatively little danger to life compared with motor vehicles. Around 2000 people are killed on UK's roads every year and cycle/pedestrian collisions account for less than 0.5% of that figure. People who cycle on pavement do so because the roads have become too hostile.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoFirst of all, don't be so rude!
When I say necessary cars, I mean blue badge holders, other disabled people etc (I'm disabled myself, but can use public transport)
Cycles on pavements are EXTREMELY dangerous. I speak from exerience of...
Show full commentFirst of all, don't be so rude!
When I say necessary cars, I mean blue badge holders, other disabled people etc (I'm disabled myself, but can use public transport)
Cycles on pavements are EXTREMELY dangerous. I speak from exerience of observing manic behaviour by pavement cyclists in Camden at east every other day, and having seen 2 people I know personally badly injured by cyclists riding on pavements, It's also ILLEGAL to do so.
If people are too scared to cycle on the road where they belong, that;s just too bad, they shouldn't cycle at all.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoWhen will you get your heads round the idea that some vehicles do have to come into London, for deliveries, etc.? The bus lanes on, e.g., the Embankment have made pollution worse because they have slowed vehicular traffic down to a crawl.
Show full commentWhen will you get your heads round the idea that some vehicles do have to come into London, for deliveries, etc.? The bus lanes on, e.g., the Embankment have made pollution worse because they have slowed vehicular traffic down to a crawl.
Show less of commentgmg57
Community Member 6 years agoi presume you mean the cycle lanes on the embankment.
Show full commenti presume you mean the cycle lanes on the embankment.
Show less of commentJosecool69
Community Member 6 years agoAbsolutely pointless unless you ban cycling too.
Have a day of bicycle registration, oblige them to have insurance and test to see that they are road worthy and the riders know the Highway Code.
The idea that you blame cars for the city’s...
Show full commentAbsolutely pointless unless you ban cycling too.
Have a day of bicycle registration, oblige them to have insurance and test to see that they are road worthy and the riders know the Highway Code.
The idea that you blame cars for the city’s increased pollution is madness. Cars have improved their emissions. So what has changed? Traffic calming, longer travelling times, greater time waiting at traffic lights, reduced number of lanes to welcome non existent bicycle traffic, ... I could go on.
If you are serious about reducing car pollution, introduce a scrap scheme for previously duped drivers to change to hybrid/electric cars.
Cars are here to stay. Stop attacking motorists who need their cars on a pretence of a green policy!
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoAnd accelerate plans for the installation of electric car charging points throughout the city.
Show full commentAnd accelerate plans for the installation of electric car charging points throughout the city.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 6 years agoFind the solutions to the stabbings and it may be safe to go to such events, get your priorities right!
Show full commentFind the solutions to the stabbings and it may be safe to go to such events, get your priorities right!
Show less of commentGemmar
Community Member 6 years agoThis is an idea I held for a long time, since, many years ago there was a street party in Upper Street, Islington and the whole Upper street from Angel to Highbury and Islington was taken over by pedestrians only. It was on Sunday I think...
Show full commentThis is an idea I held for a long time, since, many years ago there was a street party in Upper Street, Islington and the whole Upper street from Angel to Highbury and Islington was taken over by pedestrians only. It was on Sunday I think. The atmosphere was like one of a big family eating at a long table that stretched from Angel to Highbury and Islington tube station. For one day I felt human again among humans and not a mechanical 9 to 5 robot.
lets have more streets closed to polluting traffic. Let’s plant more trees which absorb more carbon dioxide, keep down noise from traffic and keep the nearby buildings cooler in summer, so no need of using to much energy for air conditioners etc.
i would suggest having a regular shutdown to traffic every Sunday except for emergency services.
gmg57
Community Member 6 years agoSbork - some of us actually live in central London and would like to be able to go about our business without vast swathes of roads cut off for what appears to be no more than a vanity project to allow people to potter into central London...
Show full commentSbork - some of us actually live in central London and would like to be able to go about our business without vast swathes of roads cut off for what appears to be no more than a vanity project to allow people to potter into central London because it seems like a nice idea on their bikes. It will have no real practical impact.
Show less of commentSbork
Community Member 6 years agoReally looking forward to this event, just wanted to add some positivity. interested to see how the city feels in certain areas without the slow moving traffic, noise and pollution. As many have said there needs to be consideration for...
Show full commentReally looking forward to this event, just wanted to add some positivity. interested to see how the city feels in certain areas without the slow moving traffic, noise and pollution. As many have said there needs to be consideration for people that rely on a car to get around, but I can't imagine this hasn't been thought of seeing as joe bloggs on the internet is flagging it up.
My first thought was how excited I was to cycle on car free roads. My boyfriend is a keen cyclist and when we have gone for short trips out around our local area in Walthamstow it's made me more nervous with drivers not indicating and pulling out in front of us. I know angry drivers always flag up bad cyclist jumping red lights ect, which I know some do, I've seen it, but cyclists are in the miniority on the roads so those types of cyclists are the miniorty. However a similar percentage of car drivers are also terrible road users, jsut becuase you pass a test to drive doesn't make everyone careful and competent. I always spot a least 2 or 3 people on mobiles a day despite the fact it's illegal.
Why can't people do like they do with motorcyclists and Think Bike, they are harder to spot and much smaller and more vunrable than car drivers so there needs to be some consideration which is not what I have experienced as a cyclist. Just taking a bit more care will not stop anyone getting from A to B. I am waiting for the vitriol to pour out regarding this as cyclists v drivers seems such a devisive topic, another way we are split and it seems neither party will ever compromise or agree. But my main point was I'm very excited to get out on the road and cycle as far as I can on car free roads!
tonydoona
Community Member 6 years agoSbork
Surely if the roads are closed for the day, events taking place, street parties and mass celebrations taking place, cyclists will also be banned from these areas, Whilst I appreciate they are special, surely the cycling fraternity...
Show full commentSbork
Surely if the roads are closed for the day, events taking place, street parties and mass celebrations taking place, cyclists will also be banned from these areas, Whilst I appreciate they are special, surely the cycling fraternity would frown upon their members ignoring these restrictions and forcing their way through
Show less of commentSbork
Community Member 6 years agoIn my local area yes I might not be able to cycle through where people are having parties, but I'm thinking more of cycling around central London in areas I would be too scared to normally, Obviously the plans havne't been finalised yet...
Show full commentIn my local area yes I might not be able to cycle through where people are having parties, but I'm thinking more of cycling around central London in areas I would be too scared to normally, Obviously the plans havne't been finalised yet, but I'm excited about the prospect of places I would not notmally go being more accessable by bike. This is a forum to talk about what you would like from that day, and this is it, or making it easier to cylce to an area having a celebration or a party by bike is a nice prospect.
Show less of commentclaudesnudge
Community Member 6 years agoGood idea but please stop demonising the car. I am a retired district nurse and I would have been unable to undertake my work without a car. Don't agree with all the road closures as those living on the main roads are suffering more...
Show full commentGood idea but please stop demonising the car. I am a retired district nurse and I would have been unable to undertake my work without a car. Don't agree with all the road closures as those living on the main roads are suffering more polution. Many older folk are unable to cycle so we all need to be more tolerant.
Show less of commentEdwardsT
Community Member 6 years agoAs a nurse, you will you be fully aware of the ill-effects of air pollution and the harm which cars cause to life through collisions (injury and death). I think society has tolerated the car enough! And it's has to stop. Just look at the...
Show full commentAs a nurse, you will you be fully aware of the ill-effects of air pollution and the harm which cars cause to life through collisions (injury and death). I think society has tolerated the car enough! And it's has to stop. Just look at the state of our streets! They're clogged with parked cars (the RAC Foundation reports that cars are only ever in use 4% of the time) and the rest of the road space is clogged with cars trying to move (often failing to do so because of other cars!). We have a climate crisis, an air and noise pollution problem, an obesity epidemic and unsafe roads (circa 2000 people die on UK's roads every year). And local businesses are closing because people drive to supermarkets far from home which have gargantuan car parks. It's clear we have tolerated the car for long enough, and it's high time we started undoing the damage they've caused to life (both to humans and wildlife) and our town and cities. Many older people would love to cycle given the chance, but are too afraid to do so on our horrible roads. See here: https://cyclingfallacies.com/en/5/i'm-too-old-to-cycle
Show less of commentWilliam Everett
Community Member 6 years agoThis is a typical show-off gesture by someone who likes to be bossy. Just leave it alone and get on with your actual job as Mayor of London.
Show full commentThis is a typical show-off gesture by someone who likes to be bossy. Just leave it alone and get on with your actual job as Mayor of London.
Show less of commentSomeone
Community Member 6 years agoPromoting public health is part of the Mayor's job, though many commenting here don't like it.
Show full commentPromoting public health is part of the Mayor's job, though many commenting here don't like it.
Show less of commentkrlondon
Community Member 6 years agoAnd if street parties and play streets are your idea of a nightmare and a complete inconvenience - your opinions don’t count? I walk, cycle, use public transport and drive when I need to. Why not live and let live?
Show full commentAnd if street parties and play streets are your idea of a nightmare and a complete inconvenience - your opinions don’t count? I walk, cycle, use public transport and drive when I need to. Why not live and let live?
Show less of commentsally700
Community Member 6 years agoYep, I loathe street parties.
Show full commentYep, I loathe street parties.
Show less of commentJsRoberts
Community Member 6 years agoI hope they are going to liase with rail and underground providers, as normaly sunday is the day they close or have a restricted service. A relative is often a patient in barts hospital near st pauls and the only way i have been able to...
Show full commentI hope they are going to liase with rail and underground providers, as normaly sunday is the day they close or have a restricted service. A relative is often a patient in barts hospital near st pauls and the only way i have been able to visiit on a weekend is by car.
I used to work and drive in lodon 20 years ago, but the only time i go now is to visit the hospital as it has become like a foreign city which i no longer recognise.
Show less of commentCMW
Community Member 6 years agoBrilliant! Yes please! I have been waiting for this for years. Great to raise conciousness about only using the car when really necessary and to give an impression of how beautiful London could be with less traffic and smelly cars but more...
Show full commentBrilliant! Yes please! I have been waiting for this for years. Great to raise conciousness about only using the car when really necessary and to give an impression of how beautiful London could be with less traffic and smelly cars but more space to cycle and walk safely.
Show less of commentzigfarria
Community Member 6 years agoAgree! High-density cities with narrow roads are not well-suited to cars. I always hope that as I cycle past rows of waiting cars that I will inspire some motorists to try cycling instead.
Show full commentAgree! High-density cities with narrow roads are not well-suited to cars. I always hope that as I cycle past rows of waiting cars that I will inspire some motorists to try cycling instead.
Show less of commentgmg57
Community Member 6 years agoCMW - I think the point of the majority here is that you cannot walk safely due to a not insignificant proportion of irresponsible cyclists. We can’t all be imagining it.
Terry Vaughan - for clarity I am not a black cab driver or related...
Show full commentCMW - I think the point of the majority here is that you cannot walk safely due to a not insignificant proportion of irresponsible cyclists. We can’t all be imagining it.
Terry Vaughan - for clarity I am not a black cab driver or related to one. But I cannot share your view that they are worse than mini cabs. Perhaps tfl should focus on reducing the licences handed out to mini cab drivers for a small amount of money with no training, no vehicle or security checks of any note. It would also reduce the number of cars on the road (thousands more than not very many years ago) and the pollution from them sitting on residential streets with engines on waiting for their next fare.
Show less of comment