Commissioner for Social Housing Residents
The Mayor has proposed that the Prime Minister appoint a Commissioner for Social Housing Residents.
The Mayor has proposed that the Prime Minister appoint a Commissioner for Social Housing Residents, which he believes should be independent of government with a remit to act as a watchdog. This will help ensure that the voices of social housing residents are heard at national level when policy is being developed.
What do you think of this proposal? What impact do you think it will have?
The discussion ran from 06 September 2017 - 08 December 2017
Closed
Want to join our next discussion?
New here? Join Talk London, City Hall's online community where you can have your say on London's biggest issues.
Join Talk LondonAlready have an account?
Log into your accountmariathena
Community Member 7 years agoThe Councils or Commissioners office if it happens, need to do a thorough AUDIT on social housing properties.
There is a corrupted issue that needs to be addressed:
Show full commentIt has become apparent that many social housing residents are illegally...
The Councils or Commissioners office if it happens, need to do a thorough AUDIT on social housing properties.
There is a corrupted issue that needs to be addressed:
It has become apparent that many social housing residents are illegally subletting their dwellings , either cash to illegal immigrants or peddling them on rental internet platforms for flats, rooms etc.
Many people genuinely in need of social housing are left out , as properties have been given to others who make a business out of it hoping they will not be found out. They should be found out and taken out of these properties who should them be given to other applicants
Show less of commentShane
Community Member 7 years agoWhile broadly positive, my main concerns with the proposals are:
- How many affordable homes are planned to be built, and what is the baseline for "affordable"? I would hope it would be accessible to the 70% of Londoners who earn less than...
Show full commentWhile broadly positive, my main concerns with the proposals are:
- How many affordable homes are planned to be built, and what is the baseline for "affordable"? I would hope it would be accessible to the 70% of Londoners who earn less than £30k, especially as a substantial amount can only afford properties with the aid of housing benefit, and those who have dependents also have to ensure they have money for childcare and/or carers.
- Also it's worrying if land ownership will go to developers rather than councils. It may prioritise profit over accessibility, as developers are running a business, not a public service.
- I feel the most important thing is to give residents a loud voice in this matter. It would be good if a small group of residents with housing know-how had a seat at the table when the proposals for the change in housing policy are finialised.
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 7 years agoI get very angry when ministers etc keep referring to social housing as " AFFORDABLE HOUSING"! Properties are only affordable if you are within that budget/income. Most people are NOT!!!!! Change the wording and lower some of the rents...
Show full commentI get very angry when ministers etc keep referring to social housing as " AFFORDABLE HOUSING"! Properties are only affordable if you are within that budget/income. Most people are NOT!!!!! Change the wording and lower some of the rents within the councils and housing associations. This needs addressing ASAP.
Show less of commentTalk London
Official Representative 7 years agoThank you everyone for sharing your views. Many of you agree with the proposal of a Commissioner for Social Housing Residents.
We asked our Housing Team for more details about the role of the Commissioner. Here's what they said:
"The Commissioner would have the same powers as the Children’s Commissioner, which means:
• Powers to get access to information required to carry out investigations.
• Powers of access to relevant places for investigating purposes.
• Powers to require responses from those to whom recommendations are aimed at."
Talk London
kemiA
Community Member 7 years agoAlso would they have the power to fine and fix issues that occur. Social landlords will only take heed if the end result of not doing anything will hit their profits.
A Social Housing commissioner sounds like a good idea, but I think only...
Show full commentAlso would they have the power to fine and fix issues that occur. Social landlords will only take heed if the end result of not doing anything will hit their profits.
A Social Housing commissioner sounds like a good idea, but I think only as a trial for 3 years or so to assess whether they are effective and worth the money.
Show less of commentgreenwich1
Community Member 7 years agoI was born in London
Show full commentI joined the social housing register at the age of 16,27 years later I signed my first social housing tenancy.
So far all my adult life I am lucky to have been in paid employment this is down to me working hard...
I was born in London
I joined the social housing register at the age of 16,27 years later I signed my first social housing tenancy.
So far all my adult life I am lucky to have been in paid employment this is down to me working hard.
Having had this social housing tenancy for five years now. I have reported to my social housing landlord within these five years. That mortar continues to fall off the roof of my home. My social housing landlord had put the plumbing for the washing machine in what was the old outside toilet every time I need to use the washing machine I have to get address go out into the outside garden and then open the door to what was the old outside toilet in order to use the washing machine. The kitchen is not fit for purpose; only one person can be in the kitchen at any one time, there is no food preparation workspace. When I try to open the door to the oven the oven door hits the base unit to the kitchen sink that is opposite to the oven/cooker. So the oven door cannot open safely, I have to lean sideways to take hot food out of the oven
If I hadn't taken this property as seen I was told in writing that I would loose my housing priority. All I want is for my landlord to address these issues. My housing provider just seems to drag tenants through complaints procedures stage1, stage 2 and so on just trying to wear tenants down, hopping us social housing tenants just given up and shut up.
Yes their needs to by some sort of social housing commissioning body/panel made up of people that have lived in social housing and that is independent of Government and Social housing providers.
Show less of commentWelsh allan
Community Member 7 years agoam a social housing renter, the sector needs all the help it can get
Anonymous - account deleted
Community Member 7 years agoI agree, a commissioner would be a start to redress the Tory Policy to decimate Social Housing under the guise of austerity.
Some other suggestions...
Firstly, take all Social Housing away from Council/Local Authority control. All social...
Show full commentI agree, a commissioner would be a start to redress the Tory Policy to decimate Social Housing under the guise of austerity.
Some other suggestions...
Firstly, take all Social Housing away from Council/Local Authority control. All social housing should be managed by Housing Associations or charitable not for profits with no political leanings.
The term 'Affordable Housing' should never be used for Social Housing. It has only Tory MPs an excuse to include properties let more like private accommodation, just 20% cheaper than current market rents.
Scrap bedroom tax and allow greater freedom for social tenants to (short term) sublet, holiday let rooms, etc. and take in lodgers (priority for those on housing waiting lists).
I could go on.
Show less of commentElizabethS
Community Member 7 years agoIf the lead person of this is a social tenant her/himself with relevant expertise, and there are plenty of other diverse tenants paid to contribute, and it is not another layer of comfortably-waged people kindly patronising the plebs with...
Show full commentIf the lead person of this is a social tenant her/himself with relevant expertise, and there are plenty of other diverse tenants paid to contribute, and it is not another layer of comfortably-waged people kindly patronising the plebs with hideous engagement exercises, it is good.
Show less of commenttonydoona
Community Member 7 years agoThis is just one more example of Sadiq trying to blame other people and create an impression of doing something for Londoners whilst actually doing nothing.
Show full commentIt is time our mayor got out from behind his desk, made his own decisions and...
This is just one more example of Sadiq trying to blame other people and create an impression of doing something for Londoners whilst actually doing nothing.
Show less of commentIt is time our mayor got out from behind his desk, made his own decisions and actually did something useful. you cannot spend a full term in office trying to criticize central government and develop a position as an official opposition figure.
natasha langridge
Community Member 7 years agoWe need to protect the social housing we already have instead of flogging it off to developers. Kahn hasnt done that. And we need to build more decent social housing. Will a commissioner do that?
Killajoe
Community Member 7 years agoAS I was recently reminded, the purpose of social housing was to create properties that were available to ordinary working people at a controlled rent so that people could go to work and live in their own homes without being exploited by...
Show full commentAS I was recently reminded, the purpose of social housing was to create properties that were available to ordinary working people at a controlled rent so that people could go to work and live in their own homes without being exploited by unscrupulous landlords. They would also have the dignity of not having to claim housing benefit in order to live. It also meant that ordinary people were protected from the consequences of unrestricted and uncontrolled market forces and were given a buffer against the kind of profiteering that is only too evident today in residential housing.
Show less of commentThere is a clear need for someone to be accountable at the highest level particularly when social housing is under attack from central government policy. It is unsupportable that social housing rents should be in any way linked to the volatile and fictitious figure of "market rents" and should instead reamain linked to the salaries of the lowest paid workers who are those who are most likely to need them. People shouldn't have to become financial slaves just to have a roof over their heads.
There needs to be REAL affordability and not this current mockery of a system which has so distorted the word "affordable".
brendak142
Community Member 7 years agoYes a good idea but only if s/he has some powers to achieve recommendations; just another chat room for airing grievances would be a waste of time and monehy.
c-d
Community Member 7 years agoAn independent Commissioner for Social Housing Residents! Another title another salary and I suspect they will have no power and will be ignored when policy is being developed. They would need to have some form of power to be able to do...
Show full commentAn independent Commissioner for Social Housing Residents! Another title another salary and I suspect they will have no power and will be ignored when policy is being developed. They would need to have some form of power to be able to do any good.
Show less of commentJAXM
Community Member 7 years agoThere is a large office block on the North Circular road that has been empty for at least fifteen years why can't this be knocked down and flats built? You could get a lot of properties on that footprint and house a lot of people but it...
Show full commentThere is a large office block on the North Circular road that has been empty for at least fifteen years why can't this be knocked down and flats built? You could get a lot of properties on that footprint and house a lot of people but it seems it better to leave it empty and let it get vandalised.
Show less of commentThere should be some sort of process that if any properties( both residential and commercial) have been empty for a considerable amount of time then they local authority should have the power to compulsory purchase and convert it to social or affordable housing
c-d
Community Member 7 years agoJAXM - Agreed. Though it will never happen with the Conservatives in power. This would need Jeremy at the helm.The same should go for overseas purchasers that leave brand new apartments empty just waiting to sell it on for a profit at a...
Show full commentJAXM - Agreed. Though it will never happen with the Conservatives in power. This would need Jeremy at the helm.The same should go for overseas purchasers that leave brand new apartments empty just waiting to sell it on for a profit at a later time. We have a severe lack of housing and properties stood empty, pure madness. This M Thatchers legacy. Sell off all council stock as they cannot afford to manage/upkeep telling the common people that all should have the chance of owing their own home. A shambles.
Show less of commentDragon316
Community Member 7 years agoA Commissioner for Social Housing would be good but to be effective he would need to be supported by legislation and a large back-up team of qualified people to be able to enforce his decisions.
Show full commentThe biggest problem today is the Conservative...
A Commissioner for Social Housing would be good but to be effective he would need to be supported by legislation and a large back-up team of qualified people to be able to enforce his decisions.
Show less of commentThe biggest problem today is the Conservative Party mistakenly think that market forces will resolve the housing problem.
The Government must change their policies to actually help the community to resolve the Housing problem.
I believe that that Estate Agents should not be involved in letting residential properties unless they sign up to a code of practice.
I believe that all Houses and Flats to be let out should have minimum square footage sizes, and which must include a separate kitchen, bathroom, toilet and living room and be for a prior agreed number of residents.
All properties to be rented out must be licensed by the Local Council for a reasonable Licence fee. The Fee must include an inspection by Surveyors appointed to ensure to properties do not have any damp, all the electrics and gas are of a safe standard and the owners have bought an approved Property Maintenance Insurance Bond which is registered with the Local Authority.
All properties that do not meet the terms of the Rental licence should be compulsorily purchased by the Local Authority, refurbished to an acceptable standard and let out by the Local Authority as social housing.
JAXM
Community Member 7 years agoI totally agree with your comments. The Commissioner has to be supported by legislation and actually have the power to do anything. The ideal situation would be to have something like a Social Housing Ombudsman who could deal with...
Show full commentI totally agree with your comments. The Commissioner has to be supported by legislation and actually have the power to do anything. The ideal situation would be to have something like a Social Housing Ombudsman who could deal with individual cases>
Show less of commentTotally agree with your suggestion that there should be a minimum square footage. Where I live in Harrow some of the studio flats are minute but that is all a single person is entitled to under the LHA.
Private landlords aren't checked up on so they can get away with substandard properties. The cost of rental in this area is prohibitive and means many families are living in over grounded conditions.
tssoaamanda
Community Member 7 years agoI'm in total agreement with all your points.
Anonymous - account deleted
Community Member 7 years agoI believe it will certainly help tenants to get their voices heard. Of course, some LAs and HAs are excellent with their tenants, but others may not be. If it helps fairness and can deal with grievances, then it can only be a good thing...
Show full commentI believe it will certainly help tenants to get their voices heard. Of course, some LAs and HAs are excellent with their tenants, but others may not be. If it helps fairness and can deal with grievances, then it can only be a good thing, but fairness on all sides is imperative.
Show less of commentmulligan
Community Member 7 years agoIf the commissioner has power, ok. If not, not.
guy_allott
Community Member 7 years agoAppointing a commisioner does not necessarily solve problems, and would probably only serve as a place for people to aim their frustrations rather than be a tool for change.
Paul Bowers
Community Member 7 years agoi'd love to be able to get a social housing property
i'm disabled, live in an inappropriate property for me needs but cant get what i need especially as i occasionally need a second bedroom for a carer
Show full commenti'd love to be able to get a social housing property
i'm disabled, live in an inappropriate property for me needs but cant get what i need especially as i occasionally need a second bedroom for a carer
Show less of commentAnonymous - account deleted
Community Member 7 years agoI agree with you as being disabled myself yet no property for the disabled.
natasha langridge
Community Member 7 years agowe need a better Government. Hopefully we will get one soon. These ones are wreckers and murderers.
Show full commentwe need a better Government. Hopefully we will get one soon. These ones are wreckers and murderers.
Show less of comment