Celebrating and recognising our diversity across London's public realm

What suggestions do you have to celebrate and recognise London’s diversity across the public realm?

User Image for
Added by Talk London

Up vote 2
Care 0

London is one of the most diverse cities in the world. There are more than 300 languages spoken every day, yet statues, plaques and street names don’t reflect the capital’s diverse population and history. 

City Hall is recruiting a Commission for Diversity in the Public Realm.  Once set up in December, the Commission will work with boroughs and communities to ensure our street names, squares, statues and monuments tell the full story of London's rich diversity, which includes people from Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic backgrounds, women, LGTBQI+, disabled groups and people from socio-economically disadvantaged backgrounds.
 
Since the announcement of the Commission, City Hall has received a lot of suggestions from Londoners. For example:

  • sculpture trails
  • bus stations to celebrate black bus drivers
  • new murals

What do you think of these suggestions?

Imagine there were more sites that tell the stories of women, people from Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic backgrounds, LGTBQI+, disabled groups or self-made and working class Londoners. What suggestions do you have to celebrate and recognise London’s diversity across the public realm?

This discussion is co-moderated by the GLA Communities and Social Policy unit who are co-leading the Commission with the GLA Culture and Creative Industries unit.

Closed


Want to join our next discussion?

New here? Join Talk London, City Hall's online community where you can have your say on London's biggest issues.

Join Talk London

Already have an account?

Log into your account
Comments (195)

Avatar for - Orangutan
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

 I think the major issue here is the budget involved & who pays for it. Some of the Victorian statues have the inscription "By Public Subscription"  on them & bI think one has the rider " of whom ythe most numerous were common soldiers" (I...

Show full comment

 I think the major issue here is the budget involved & who pays for it. Some of the Victorian statues have the inscription "By Public Subscription"  on them & bI think one has the rider " of whom ythe most numerous were common soldiers" (I think that was on General Havelock in Trafalgar Square.  It would be interesting to know how existing statues were paid for & whether we are prepared to pay up for new ones. Probably not so much of a priority at present. That aside, who should be represented ? Alan Turing is now an LGBTQ icon although we might want a memorial to him for sort of winning WW2. Black campaigners fir the abolition of slavery seem to get obscured - Olaudah Equiano & Ignacio Sanchez. I can't see how street names & Blue Plaques can be that expensive. I am the most white English person I know, but given the number of black people in London historically, such people are most likely amongst my ancestors.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

I am totally beyond disgusted by these proposals.   Stop wasting our money and make efforts to restore London to a place we were once proud of.  Concentrate on increased crime.  Stop adding cycle lanes, causing traffic chaos whilst...

Show full comment

I am totally beyond disgusted by these proposals.   Stop wasting our money and make efforts to restore London to a place we were once proud of.  Concentrate on increased crime.  Stop adding cycle lanes, causing traffic chaos whilst punishing car and trade vehicle owners.   London is dying and people were staying away from it, even before covid.

You, Mr Khan, are destroying our city.

 

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Tiger
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

I definitely agree we should instead be focusing on making London the city we can be proud of again. And this initiative is a total waste of time and money. But getting more people cycling and reducing polluting old cars and taxis has to be...

Show full comment

I definitely agree we should instead be focusing on making London the city we can be proud of again. And this initiative is a total waste of time and money. But getting more people cycling and reducing polluting old cars and taxis has to be good, no? Sorry if this impacts your livelihood - I sympathise with that if it does. 

Show less of comment

Avatar for - American pika
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

I am a "minority" immigrant in London, and I do not want to see London change to fit me and my culture.

So what you are proposing is that you want to force-represent  "Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic backgrounds, women, LGTBQI+, disabled...

Show full comment

I am a "minority" immigrant in London, and I do not want to see London change to fit me and my culture.

So what you are proposing is that you want to force-represent  "Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic backgrounds, women, LGTBQI+, disabled groups and people from socio-economically disadvantaged backgrounds"  in street names, squares, statues and monuments. 

If there are well-known black historical figures then sure, go ahead and celebrate them as part of UK history and creating NEW monuments, not replacing or re-branding existing ones. While I understand that under-represented groups should have fair opportunity and ablity to represent themselves in London, they should never force diversity and ironically, be over-represented than others. 

Also why is this obsession with diversity and forced representation at all? London represents England, it's history, not the plaques. statues and street names of 300 langauges spoken in it. It's absurd to think this as a problem for London. 

Under the banner of "diversity" all is done is removal of "problematic" statues which are part of British history in very violent, aggressive and self-shaming manner, completelty not civil or a just way. Diversity basically means anti-white and especially anti-white-male. We all know that.

What is the point of celebrating black bus drivers? Why segragate a race in one proffesion and celebrate that? Sounds racist to me.

You want to celebrate bus drivers? OK. Why celebrate speicifc colours of their skin? Whats there to celebrate in it? A celebration of one skin colour is dangerously similar to what actual fascists approve. 

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Staghorn coral
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Well said :-)

Avatar for - Staghorn coral
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Another Commission? what value will they bring?

Money is better spent on real world issues such as overall Transport Infrastucture, Education, Housing etc. 

Avatar for - Tiger
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Well said!! :)

Avatar for - American pika
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Ironic that intolerance seems to be surfacing here (GLA consultation on public realm) during 2020 National Hate Crime Awareness Week 

So hope I'm NOT gonna get flamed for my anodyne suggestion that Public Realm should take more account of...

Show full comment

Ironic that intolerance seems to be surfacing here (GLA consultation on public realm) during 2020 National Hate Crime Awareness Week 

So hope I'm NOT gonna get flamed for my anodyne suggestion that Public Realm should take more account of level access to better meet needs of many groups of Londoners  - people with prams, with wheelchairs, people with limiting health conditions, people carrying stuff etc - so YES to more Sculpture/Art trails, more/better signage at significant transport nodes and more cool street art - but can we make sure they are (and remain) accessible 

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

How about you stop wasting our money on this stuff and put some serious effort in tackling crime (real crime... you now stuff like burglaries and gangs) and other real social plagues like litter?? This city in literally drowning in trash...

Show full comment

How about you stop wasting our money on this stuff and put some serious effort in tackling crime (real crime... you now stuff like burglaries and gangs) and other real social plagues like litter?? This city in literally drowning in trash and it gets worse every day. 

If you want to celebrate bus drivers give them a raise (to all not just black). 

 

 

 

 

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Tiger
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

A better use of the money is to ensure contractually that all businesses located  in London embrace diversity and inclusion with quarterly submissions of reports on their recruitment practices, promotion practices, performance review...

Show full comment

A better use of the money is to ensure contractually that all businesses located  in London embrace diversity and inclusion with quarterly submissions of reports on their recruitment practices, promotion practices, performance review practices and redundancy practices. That would get more unemployed Londoners back into employment or keep them in employment in a way changing statues and street names won't. Changing statues and street names in the public realm is just a superficial exercise that doesn't address discrimination some Londoners experience day to day.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Put plaques beside monuments, statues etc giving their history with online links to further explanations. We must learn from our past mistakes, not bury them.

As for today's favourites, how many will pass muster with future generations...

Show full comment

Put plaques beside monuments, statues etc giving their history with online links to further explanations. We must learn from our past mistakes, not bury them.

As for today's favourites, how many will pass muster with future generations? Even the saintly Attenborough admits to eating the flesh of animals. JK Rowling is already on the naughty step. The Queen's statue won't last long due to her ancestors' behaviours.

Have you ever supported military intervention? Wore leather? wool? disrepected anyone? Killed a spider? gambled? drank alcohol, taken mind-altering drugs, taken vaccines obtained through animal experiments, let alone wore cosmetics?

Let's hope future generations are not as intolerant as our current one or we're all dammed. Still, what have the future generations ever done for us?

 

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Find ways to fund such projects other than imposition on the residents of London who are overburdened already.

Let things evolve naturally rather than imposing an agenda based on divisive labels and other fake criteria.

Reflect the true...

Show full comment

Find ways to fund such projects other than imposition on the residents of London who are overburdened already.

Let things evolve naturally rather than imposing an agenda based on divisive labels and other fake criteria.

Reflect the true history of London and the UK and not some idealised version of it.

Do not try to enforce conformity on the London public, it will be ignored. 

 

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Another waste of money from a Mayor that is only interested in himself, his ego, and his self publicity! The chance to get a decent Mayor cannot come too soon!! 

Avatar for - Vaquita
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Celebrating our past and present is important if we want to build towards our future, but this celebration needs to be carefully measured so that we do not celebrate the good by excluding or covering up the bad. We need to be honest about...

Show full comment

Celebrating our past and present is important if we want to build towards our future, but this celebration needs to be carefully measured so that we do not celebrate the good by excluding or covering up the bad. We need to be honest about our past and give long overdue attention to those that have been edited out of our history. 

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Avatar image
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Hi Rev Alex. 

Thanks for raising this point. One element that the commission will consider is how we can tell a more accurate story of our city and its history through public realm. The scope will be wide and include commemoration, murals, street art, street names and memorials. We are reiewing all comments and will be sure to feed back your suggestions. 

Commission for Diversity in the Public Realm Team.

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Yet another waste of money idea from from the biggest waste of money that the London Council tax payers are forced to fund. Maybe a better idea is to scrap the post of Mayor and get rid of he useless bunch of deputies. Hopefully the people...

Show full comment

Yet another waste of money idea from from the biggest waste of money that the London Council tax payers are forced to fund. Maybe a better idea is to scrap the post of Mayor and get rid of he useless bunch of deputies. Hopefully the people of London will vote out the present totally useless mayor. Then we might get a proper person who can do the job. Maybe Mt Khan could do Londoners a favour and resign!!! Taking the Fat Cst advisors and hangers on with him.

Show less of comment

Avatar for - Tiger
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Remove all the monarchical names from streets, squares, roads, buildings and replace them with the names of artists, doctors, poets, dramatists, inventors and half must be women. Represent the people not the ruling elite who were never...

Show full comment

Remove all the monarchical names from streets, squares, roads, buildings and replace them with the names of artists, doctors, poets, dramatists, inventors and half must be women. Represent the people not the ruling elite who were never democratically elected.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

This really is not a good idea, who is actually asking for this? You are causing division and tension when we really do not need it -Please stop it. Londoners get on fine as we are, you are making a problem not addressing one. Wasting money...

Show full comment

This really is not a good idea, who is actually asking for this? You are causing division and tension when we really do not need it -Please stop it. Londoners get on fine as we are, you are making a problem not addressing one. Wasting money and time that could be better spent elsewhere....on our children would be a good start

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Sorry to burst your "fine" bubble, but Londoners are far from fine especially the BAME Londoners!! A massive problem is amongst us right now and it's called INEQUALITY!!!!!! 

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Why not celebrate the achievements of Londoners as people without regard to these sub classifications. Obsession with increasingly granular subdivisions of humanity is divisive 

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Rather than being embarassed by the actions by some in the past, can we not move towards being more positive? Sport plays an important part of many lives, so should we think of marking this in our towns and various sport locations?  We...

Show full comment

Rather than being embarassed by the actions by some in the past, can we not move towards being more positive? Sport plays an important part of many lives, so should we think of marking this in our towns and various sport locations?  We already have commemorative "heritage" plaques on buildings:  so how about stainless steel plaques set into the pavement to recognise past champions near the gyms, sports centres, courts and pitches that were their base and inspiration?   

One should also remember that there is a need to be rigorous: as an example, in 1988 Selous Street in Camden Town was seen by the Council to have links to the Selous Scouts, a body set up in 1973 that did not find favour with some in Southern Africa. 

The name was therefore changed (at some expense) by the Council.  Subsequently it transpired that the Victorian street was not named after the militaristic group, but seemingly after a local person of the Victorian/Edwardian era, described as it happens as an early "conservationist". 

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

It is laudable to recognise London's diversity but great care must be taken not to over empasise the diversity in the past. Quotas should be avoided and the criteria used in chosing who to commemorate, in any way, should be impartial as to...

Show full comment

It is laudable to recognise London's diversity but great care must be taken not to over empasise the diversity in the past. Quotas should be avoided and the criteria used in chosing who to commemorate, in any way, should be impartial as to colour, sex, sexual orientation etc and based purely on merit.

Show less of comment

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

"Talk London" why have you ignored most of the comments against the proposal? Please stop push the race hate agenda. 

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

Hi everyone and thank you for sharing your views and suggestions in this discussion.

Some of you have asked why City Hall is setting up this Commission. The Mayor is committed to ensuring that the capital’s population and history are celebrated and commemorated. The idea for the Commission came about in 2018, following the unveiling of the statue of suffragist leader Millicent Fawcett in Parliament Square, the first statue of a woman in the Square. And more recently, the Black Lives Matter movement has raised the importance of diverse representation in our society as a matter of urgency.

A few of you have mentioned involving local communities in the process. Once set-up, the Commission will indeed work with London boroughs and partners across the city. It will make recommendations for new commissions, including of statues, memorials, blue plaques, commemorations, murals, street art, street names and more; provide an overview of existing public art and the public realm in London; and create best practice on commissioning works.

Imagine there were more sites that tell the stories of women, people from Black, Asian and Minority Ethnic backgrounds, LGTBQI+, disabled groups or self-made and working class Londoners. What suggestions do you have to celebrate and recognise London’s diversity across the public realm?

Talk London

Avatar for -
Up vote 0
Care 0
Report

I do agree that 'hidden history' should be told, but that does not mean that existing history should be ignored. As one of the comments said, the people remembered by statues might have done evil, but they also did good. Statues should not...

Show full comment

I do agree that 'hidden history' should be told, but that does not mean that existing history should be ignored. As one of the comments said, the people remembered by statues might have done evil, but they also did good. Statues should not be removed but perhaps have plaques attached giving details of their achievements AND their failings.

It is important to preserve a balance. You mention working class Londoners.  I have seen an excellent example of remembering them at the Tower Bridge museum, which shows ALL the workers involved in its construction.

Some people are against diversity because they think it's divisive - this just need not be!  It is interesting and enriching. Many of us who imagine we only have 'one' culture or background might find many if we dig a little deeper.

Show less of comment